Love and Health

The Love-Health Relationship:scientific worldview itself, if that is the only way
Dr. Gray is the author of many books includingto protect important spheres of experience that
the fabulously successful book Men are Fromhave been ejected from science's confining Eden.
Mars, Women are From Venus. Another of hisIn response, scientists and philosophers who feel
books addresses how some people or one personstrongly about the liberating potential of a spare,
in every group or organization including a family,materialistic worldview began to patrol the
will be what he calls a 'psychic drain'. There areborderlands between the high-grade knowledge
neurons that respond when a person acts ascientists have of natural systems and the
certain way and research on monkey brains inlow-grade opinions that in the view of science's
1996 showed some monkeys respond when theymost ardent defenders, dominate other spheres
see another monkey doing something. Thisof culture and lead back toward the superstitious
empathic ability can be lost or damaged in humanand authoritarian world of yester-year.
brains due to trauma such as lifelong or early life'Demarcating' science from other, less cognitively
abuse. The loss of what can be called empathyworthwhile forms of understanding was already a
can also occur with lead poisoning and there aremajor feature of Darwin's world. A line beyond
researchers in medicine that some labelwhich the Newtonian paradigm could not apply
'environmental' medical practitioners while theywas drawn at the boundary between physics and
emphasize the 'mental' part of the word, who saybiology. We have seen how hesitant Darwin was
many if not most ailments are brought on orto cross that line and what happened when he did.
exacerbated through pollution and food additivesTwentieth-century people are sometimes prone
or other things. Thus highly functional sociopathsto congratulate themselves for being above these
are often becoming our leaders while the decentquaint Victorian battles. They may have less
empaths become victims of societyreason to do so, however, than they think, for
Education, Nutrition and A Personal LOVE of mine:the fact is that throughout our own century, the
Dave and I went together to T. G. I. Friday's atsame sort of battles with emotional overtones no
Keystone at the Crossing on Indianapolis' northless charged, have been waged at the contested
side. I saw a beautiful blond woman across theline where biology meets psychology, and more
bar near the antique gas pump. It seemed thatgenerally where the natural sciences confront the
she had a halo around her head. I saw no otherhuman sciences. Dualisms between spirit and
woman and paid no attention to anything exceptmatter, and even between the mind and body,
her. Dave and I went to stand near her and hermay have been pushed to the margins of
friend. I was wearing my southern climate whiterespectable intellectual discourse. But
suit that women in Miami had thought I looked likemethodological dualisms between what is covered
a member of the Miami Dolphins in after I hadby laws and what is to be 'hermeneutically
bought it in Coral Gables. Sherry's sister had aappropriated' are still very much at the center of
friend named Rick Osney who years later said:our cultural, or rather 'two cultural', life. Cognitive
"So what do you do other than make cheap suitspsychologists and neurophysiologists are even
look good?" He was a retail clothing specialist.now busy reducing mind-states to brain-states,
Sherry was most interested in Dave; she told mewhile interpretive or humanistic psychologists are
for months after, and the truth is Dave lookedproclaiming how meaningless the world would be if
like a model and did some modeling and writing. Imind is nothing but brain. Interpretive
was so enchanted and enthusiastic that if itanthropologists are filled with horror at what
weren't for the fact that Sherry had just had awould disappear from the world if the rich cultural
partial mastectomy and needed a worshipfulpractices that seem to give meaning to our lives
admirer she would have blown me off very early,were to be shown to be little more than
if not instantly.extremely sophisticated calculations on the part of
I nattered on about all the success we were onself-interested genes. Conflicts of this sort would
the verge of achieving and the triplex we ownedhave given Darwin stomachaches almost as bad
in Toronto as well as my travels. Sherry saw thatas the ones he endured over earlier demarcation
her friend was interested in Dave. Her name wascontroversies."
Sue Ann Blackwell. Sherry wasn't impressed byHermeneuts is a new epithet for alchemists such
money or power but I guess the fact that Ias myself who OBSERVE and try to fit ALL the
thought she was the most beautiful woman I hadfacts together and don't eject anything 'from
ever met or close to it, was a deciding factor inscience's confining Eden'.
her agreeing to see me again. I had a policy about"The rhetorical pattern of these battles is still
making love within three dates over the previousdepressingly similar, in fact, to Huxley's
four years or I thought it wasn't likely to becomeconfrontation with Wilberforce. Hermeneuts ridicule
a real relationship. What stupidity, eh? The limitedscientists like Hamilton, Dawkins, and Wilson when
time available in every city made this a little morethey suggest that nothing was ever known about
justifiable than it sounds however. I remembersocial cooperation until biologists discovered kin
she went to her parents in Bloomington forselection. Reductionists in turn criticize hermeneuts,
Thanksgiving and having her prepare a simplenow transformed largely into 'culturists', for
dinner at her place during one of our early dates.bringing back ghosts and gods, just as their
She is a Libran and over six years older than me.nineteenth-century predecessors were taxed with
Libran's have the classic hourglass figure that Ibeing 'vitalists' every time they said something
love and their sign is a good fit with me. I feltabout the complexity of development. Humanists
willing to marry her even before we made love. Itidentify scientists with an outdated materialistic
was a totally ecstatic time and my infatuationreductionism. Scientists insist that hermeneutical
was complete. With 60 hours towards herintentionality is little more than disguised religion.
doctorate in education and a very loving familyPerhaps, a way out of this fruitless dialectic
that had enabled a globally conscious person thatbetween the 'two cultures', can be found if each
oozed class, Sherry was my ideal.party could give up at least one of its cherished
There was a lot of conversation and I enjoyedpreconceptions. It would be a good thing, for
her insights even if she didn't agree with meexample, if heirs of the Enlightenment {Credited
about whatever it was we were debating. Sheto Bacon, Shakespeare, Jonson and others with
was open enough to hear my stories of psychican alchemical background.} would stop thinking
things and question the science behind them andthat if cultural phenomena are not reduced to
see the possibilities. I told her that I was afraid ofsome sort of mechanism, religious authoritarianism
doing anything to cause us not to be friends but Iwill immediately flood into the breach. They should
still spoke my mind. There was no policy of threealso stop assuming that nothing is really known
dates and I was on cloud nine. She had to makeabout human beings until the spirit of reductionism
the first sexual moves. Her simple hamburgergets to work. Students of the human sciences
dinner was a disaster that we later laughed abouthave, after all, been learning things alongside
for years. Yet, despite the fact that she saw Iscientists ever since modernity began. Among
was a sweet person with all the right motivationsother things they have learned that humans are
she also feared the salesman in me. The truthindividuated as persons within the bonds of
became apparent in a couple of years as Davecultures and cultural roles, they are bound
developed a relationship with Sue Ann that hetogether with others in ways no less meaningful
was the real 'operator' and Sherry still would keepand valuable than the ways promoted by strongly
me at arms length other than sex. I wrotedualistic religions. By the same token, it would be
poems and bought roses on may occasions.helpful if advocates of the interpretive disciplines
Before I left Indianapolis for Philadelphia I hadwould. abandon a tacit assumption sometimes
made it clear I wanted to marry her.found among them that nature is so constituted
I lost 20 pounds in 19 days while taking vitaminsthat it can never accommodate the rich and
and eating my 1000 calorie two peanut buttermeaningful cultural phenomena humanists are
sandwich diet. I was proud of my body and wentdedicated to protecting, and that therefore
back to see her. I remember meeting her atcultural 'ought never' to be allowed to slip
Subway Sam's and having lunch. She told me thatcomfortably into naturalism. Humanists seem to
she couldn't see me anymore if I was going tohave internalized this belief from their reductionist
talk about marriage. Ours was to be an 'openenemies, whose commitment to materialism is
relationship' and I felt the pangs of what othergenerally inseparable from their resolve to show
women that I had known must have felt. Iup large parts of culture, especially religion, as
adjusted and we soon were sharing talk aboutillusions. These opponents, we may safely say,
our other 'friends'. In a year or so, it seemed wetake in each other's laundry."
were hurting each other. I was making moreI wonder if these authors and their reductivist
money and the business was doing well. I guessbuddies are aware that all humanists are not
you could say I was a prime target for a lot ofwithout the ability to incorporate hard physical
women who wanted wealth as part of thescience to an even higher factual degree than
package. It became increasingly superficial and Ithey do. The quantum physicists like Wigner
trusted fewer people the richer I got.(Nobel laureate), Schrödinger and Heisenberg
Sherry had a couple of problems of a medicalthink that humanistic richness is robbed by
nature. Her hypoglycemia had beenreductionist unspiritual thinking. The global reifying
miss-diagnosed and she had been given massivethrust of materialism (Dr. Boddy of U of T,
cortisone shots that I believe had contributed toanthropology) is hopefully, in due course, going to
the cancer that resulted in the partialreturn to a global deifying thrust of spiritualism.
mastectomy. Women are not treated as men areThe only REALITY is NATURE and it assuredly
when it comes to medical treatment; as well asincludes ALL observable facts not just the 'Toilet
every other aspect of misogyny in society. MyPhilosophy'.
studies of wholistics and hermetics wereIf I may be allowed to quote someone who tries
becoming quite extensive. I am going to quoteto keep an 'open mind' and use WHATEVER
authors from quite different sides of the fence.WORKS even if it isn't 'modernity'. I choose to
David Depew and Bruce Weber of MIT wrotequote a wholistic doctor by the name of Zoltan
'Darwinism Evolving' in 1995 and it says on pagesRona who has his M.D. and M. Sc. He edited the
492 & 493:'Encyclopedia of Natural Healing' in 1997 which says
"They also made it harder for the scientificon pages 33 and 34:
worldview to be received with equanimity by"It is misleading to call the natural health
other sources of culture. Indeed, since themovement 'alternative medicine' as is often done.
reducing impulse undermines fairly huge tracts ofNatural Medicine is considered the founder of
experience, people like Wallace, who feel deeplycontemporary Western medicine. What we now
about protecting phenomena they regard ascall modern medicine is actually an aberration, the
existentially important, frequently conclude thatresult of social change at the dawn of
they have no alternative except to embraceindustrialization in the eighteenth century.
spiritualism, and sometimes even to attack the